LEDs vs. CFLs
Randall Whitehead, IALD, tackles the modern-day great debate.
The artist used red LEDs to create a glow of crimson light behind this bronze, x-shaped sculpture.
Randall, will the future embrace LEDs or fluorescents? According to some experts, LEDs don’t save much more energy than fluorescents. Also, they’re not cheap—but admittedly do defray maintenance costs in commercial projects because of their extremely long life. In residential lighting this explanation doesn’t really hold, so why is there so much buzz about LEDs?
Whoa, take a breath. It’s not a competition. I think that LEDs and fluorescents will both play a big role in the future and eventually nudge incandescent lighting out altogether. Both sources are energy-efficient, but they provide two different types of light. Fluorescent is an omnidirectional source, so it is better at providing ambient (indirect or general) illumination. LEDs are a unidirectional source, so they emit better directed (accent or task) light. A cohesive lighting design will incorporate both. LEDs have a great variety of uses in commercial design. They backlight signage, and they are in exit signs, traffic lights and behind the buttons of elevators. The more intense colors—red, blue, green and yellow—have a ready use in commercial settings. It wasn’t until a more incandescent color of LED was developed that an opportunity was created for residential spaces. These newer color versions have less brightness than their deeply colored predecessors, so they work better in homes where the ceilings are lower than in commercial spaces. The artist used red LEDs to create a glow of crimson light behind this bronze, x-shaped sculpture. The artist used red LEDs to create a glow of crimson light behind this bronze, x-shaped sculpture. Some forward-thinking companies like Permlight offer an LED retrim kit that goes into existing 4-inch and 6-inch housings. They come in a screw-in variety and a hard-wire variety. The screw-in takes three minutes to install, and anyone can do it. The hard-wire version would be necessary for Title 24 compliance and should be installed by an electrician. The 6-inch has a high enough lumen output to satisfy California’s Title 24 efficacy requirements. They are incandescent in color and dim with a standard incandescent dimmer. The 6-inch versions provide 75W worth of illumination for a fraction of the energy consumption; they last 50,000 hours (as compared to 750 hours for a standard household bulb, 2,000 hours for a reflector bulb and 10,000 hours for a compact fluorescent), and they are totally green. What could be better than that?
Randall Whitehead, IALD
Latest from ask randall
You do have a tight powder room with an awkward ceiling line. I’m glad you’re thinking about cross illumination at the mirror. I would put the... read full story
Track lighting will provide you with a junction box, but not necessarily centered on the island. Usually track is fed from one end or the other. Here... read full story
You’re touching on what is the major transition point in LED lighting today. It’s not a simple matter of choosing one over the other, you have to... read full story
Archived CEU Webinar: LED Lighting 304: LEDs for Kitchens and Baths With a Focus on Dimming and Controls
This webinar has already taken place, but you can register and watch in on demand here. This webinar was sponsored by Legrand, Lightovation and Tresco Lighting. Learning... read full story
This webinar has already taken place, but you can register and watch in on demand here. Sponsored by Legrand. Webinar Overview:Learning units:AIA/CES LU (HSW) 1.0... read full story
This webinar has already taken place, but you can still watch it on demand by registering here. Sponsored by Emerson and Legrand. Webinar Overview: Learning units:AIA/... read full story